2011 Emmy Wrap Up

[Tony RuizKeymaster Joined: Nov 5th, 2010 Topics: 29 Posts: 824 View Predictions]

#223308

So what do we think?

 

I only got 12 out of 25, though I was happy that some of my spoilers were right.

 

But it is clear to me, that episode submission can no longer be seen as the key factors…there were just too many cases of inexplicable winners.  In some cases, the episodes were a help, as in the case of Jim Parsons, margo Martindale,  and Julie Bowen.  But other winners, Kyle Chandler and Peter Dinklage, clearly had something else going on.  

Reply

[sorceryMember Joined: Jul 7th, 2011 Topics: 7 Posts: 368 View Predictions]

#223310

What I’ve concluded is that the Emmy winners (and – why not? – nominees) have and always will be a jumbled mess, which is why they’re so hard to predict!

ReplyCopy URL

[TrentMember Joined: May 14th, 2011 Topics: 144 Posts: 2360 View Predictions]

#223311

I think Dinklage deserved it.

ReplyCopy URL

[Anonymous Joined: Jan 1st, 1970 Topics: Posts: View Predictions]

#223312

Chandler’s and Dinklage’s submissions justify their wins, though.

ReplyCopy URL

[Ryan_FernandParticipant Joined: May 20th, 2011 Topics: 3 Posts: 205 View Predictions]

#223313

I got 13 right.  We also found out that sentimentality is not a factor to Emmy voters (or else Carell would have won).

 

I thought it was a decent show overall.  Lynch was a non-factor as a host.  She did nothing memorable and she wasn’t used as much as I thought she would be.  The show also had a great pace (they got through the miniseries/tv movie categories pretty quickly).  

 

As for the wins I was so happy with the Martindale and FNL wins.  Unfortunately, the show ended so anti-climatically.  The Modern Family and Mad Men series wins are getting excessive.  Also, it is sad to say that Steve Carell, now officially, never won an Emmy for portraying Michael Scott (unless of course he wins a Guest Actor award in the future).

ReplyCopy URL

[MicheBelParticipant Joined: Nov 5th, 2010 Topics: 9 Posts: 81 View Predictions]

#223314

I got 12 according to Gold Derby’s selections, but if you factor in Writing and Directing nods (which I did), I got 16 right (9 wrong).

 

And I have to say, the ones I got wrong (in the case of Chandler and McCarthy) I was so over the moon happy that they were winning, it didn’t matter. I just didn’t think he could pull it off. (I haven’t yet watched his submission though.)

 

I do believe that tapes are everything. Certainly a large factor in Dinklage’s win. And I am convinced that Bowen won because she was also so prominent in Vergara’s tape. (Thought Lynch would win, because of her prominence on Wiig’s tape, but they must’ve looked at both these two (Bowen and Lynch) and decided that since Lynch won last year, better to give it to Bowen this year).

 

Happy for the Dunphys. Very happy for McCarthy. Over the moon happy for Chandler!

ReplyCopy URL