November 23, 2014 at 1:43 am #338820
Thought this critically acclaimed documentary by Laura Poitras deserves its own thread.
Saw this one twice already, and i loved it so much.
The best part of all the hoopla regarding the documentary is the conversations you have afterwards. The views, the personal opinions you have regarding the NSA spying scandal and your views regarding Government spying, and privacy.
It is currently nominated for:
– Best Feature Award (30th Annual IDA Documentary Awards 2014)
— with 6 nominations for Cinema Eye’s 8th Annual Nonfiction Film Awards
– CITIZENFOUR’ director Laura Poitras will receive DOC NYC’s first Robert and Anne Drew Award for Documentary Excellence in November.
– Best Documentary for 24th Annual Gotham Independent Film AwardsNovember 23, 2014 at 1:51 am #338822
There is currently a MASSIVE campaign going for “Citizenfour” to become the first Documentary ever nominated for a Best Picture Oscar.
Lots of supporters for this one.
Don’t know wether it will happen though….
Why ‘Citizenfour’ Deserves a Best Picture Oscar Nomination
No documentary in history has ever scored a best picture nomination at the Oscars. Not “Hoop Dreams.” Not “The War Room.” Not “Harlan County, U.S.A.” All the classics of the genre failed to make the cut, but the 2009 expansion of the best picture category to up to 10 nominees could work in the favor of “Citizenfour,” Laura Poitras’ superb documentary about National Security Agency whistleblower Edward Snowden.
SEE MORE: Awards: The Contenders
The film has been hailed by critics for holding up a mirror to our digitally connected and politically fractured present with the intensity of a modern-day “Three Days of the Condor” or “The Conversation.” Its achievement is all the more compelling because unlike those classic thrillers, “Citizenfour” is a real-life drama, with much of the action unfolding in a drab Hong Kong hotel room.
Box office has been brisk, with the film earning nearly $1 million in limited release, an impressive figure for a documentary. The doc is tailor-made to provoke a larger debate on op-ed pages and around dinner tables.
But it’s still not clear whether “Citizenfour” will even earn an invitation to the Oscars despite the reception. As Variety’s Tim Gray noted recently, the 210 filmmakers in the Academy’s documentary branch sometimes steer clear of hot-button political films, denying best documentary nods to Alex Gibney’s “We Steal Secrets: The Story of Wikileaks” and Gabriela Cowperthwaite’s “Blackfish,” for example.
Though all Academy voters are allowed to vote on best picture nominees, the film may prove too provocative. Oscar voters are older and even though Hollywood is a liberal town, Snowden is a divisive figure. Harvey Weinstein, whose Radius-TWC unit is distributing “Citizenfour,” was an outspoken critic of the whistleblower before Poitras’ film changed his mind.
Offering up a slice of cinema vérité that is bolder and more thought-provoking than almost any movie this year, there should certainly be a place for “Citizenfour” in the expanded best picture category. By bringing viewers along as journalists, Glenn Greenwald and Poitras meet with Snowden and prepare to release a series of bombshell reports on the U.S. government’s massive surveillance operations.
When the nominees pool was expanded, there was hope that it would encourage voters to include animated films, foreign movies and documentaries. It worked in the case of animated and foreign language offerings with films like “Amour” and “Up” earning well-deserved nods, but acclaimed documentaries such as “The Act of Killing” and “The Cove” didn’t make the grade.
That’s a shame and it should change. There are worthy contenders this year –”Theory of Everything” presents a portrait of marriage that is both poignant and clear-eyed; “Boyhood” is the perfect coming-of-age story; “Foxcatcher” is an unflinching descent into madness; and “Birdman” with its swooping tracking shots is a technical marvel. Yet not one has emerged as a clear favorite and several other best picture candidates seem more serviceable than galvanizing.
Nothing can match “Citizenfour” for its capacity to inspire passionate and needed debate on the modern surveillance state, the balance between national security and privacy, and the role of the media as a government watchdog. Even if viewers deplore Snowden as a traitor, they come away from Poitras’ film with a deeper understanding of what makes him tick. It’s also masterfully shot by Poitras. Her camera glides over cellphones and lingers besides computer screens as a persistent electronic whirr resounds in the backdrop creating a collage of paranoia.
To be sure, there are flaws. “Citizenfour” elides Snowden’s personal history, Greenwald mugs for the cameras at times and the film sags in its third and final act after its central character flees to Moscow and is barely glimpsed again on screen.
Yet it contains one of the year’s most ambiguous and enduring images: a shot of Snowden and his girlfriend Lindsay Mills as they prepare dinner through the window of their Moscow home. It’s unclear if this is a scene of domestic tranquility or a glimpse of a life of stultifying confinement. Did Snowden flee prison only to find a different kind of captivity?
Among a batch of Oscar contenders that offer tidy conclusions and narrative uplift, that kind of uncertainty may prove too hard to handle.November 23, 2014 at 4:21 pm #338823
I really really want to see this. I hope it comes to at least my independant theaterDecember 6, 2014 at 8:13 pm #338824
Fascinating as hell and wonderfully shot. I have been fairly distant to the whole Snowdon story minus the general basis of what he did and his Brian Williams interview but this documentary is very well done to educate the audience that doesn’t know the details. It takes a little time to get its footing but once we meet Snowdon, you can’t take your eyes or ears off the screen and what he is saying. Director Laura Poitras does a fantastic job of making us as an audience feel like we are a third journalist in the room with Snowdon getting this personal and intimate relationship with him. Some of the events captured were really well done in reactions towards other people’s reactions and the press unavailing his story. When we leave Snowdon, it dips a little because you really just want to be there with Snowdon while some of the other things were happening (which I know was impossible to do). This, and the Roger Ebert doc Life Itself, are the frontrunners for the Oscar (even has had some chatter about a very longshot chance of a Picture nomination) and I wouldn’t be disappointed if this won. Being so relevant, it does leave you with a non ending because it is still happening but you don’t want to leave you just want to stay and watch more. 4 1/2 starsRiley (the normal one, not the one who won the predictions contest)ParticipantMay 16, 2015 at 1:05 pm #338825
This thread has barely been used, so I am bumping it over to the Emmy forum to give everyone a heads-up that HBO is taking Citizenfour to the Emmys, as Oscar-eligible documentaries often are Emmy-eligible for some reason.
You must be logged in to reply to this topic.