Most Emmy Wins for Acting during an entire run of a TV Series (scripted)?

[Madson Melo Joined: Jul 25th, 2011 Topics: 20 Posts: 310 View Predictions]

#1203489738

After a quick debate, I went to research what shows have won more Emmys for acting in all categories (not counting Super Emmys and whatsoever), I came up to these shows and decided to share just in case:

DRAMA:

1. The Practice – 13 (8 in Guest)
2. Picket Fences – 10 (3 in Guest)
3. The Sopranos – 9
3. The West Wing – 9
3. Breaking Bad – 9
3. The Waltons – 9
7. Hill Street Blues – 8
7. NYPD Blue – 8
9. St. Elsewhere – 7
9. Lou Grant – 7
9. Cagney & Lacey – 7

Almost there:
– The Handmaid’s Tale – 6
– Caesar’s Hour (never seen, was this scripted?) – 6
– Thirtysomething – 6
– Columbo – 6
– Law & Order: SVU – 6 (5 in Guest)

COMEDY

1. The Mary Tyler Moore Show – 15 (1 in Guest)
2. Frasier – 13 (5 in Guest)
3. Cheers – 12 (1 in Guest)
4. All in the Family – 11
5. Everybody Loves Raymond – 10
5. Murphy Brown – 10 (5 in Guest)
5. Mad About You – 10 (6 in Guest)
8. Will & Grace – 8 (3 in Guest)
8. Taxi – 8
8. Veep – 8

Almost there:
– The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel – 6 (2 in Guest)
– M*A*S*H – 6
– Modern Family – 6
– The Andy Griffith Show – 6

Have I missed a show? Have I counted anything wrong? Let me know!

X

Reply

[adamunc Joined: Jul 5th, 2011 Topics: 10 Posts: 473 View Predictions]

#1203489757

Little different since it’s voiceover performance and some of them were juried awards, but The Simpsons has won 16 voice acting Emmys, with 10 different performers winning. (This was a quick count off the Emmy website search function.)

Nancy Cartwright
Jackie Mason
Julie Kavner
Hank Azaria (4)
Harry Shearer
Anne Hathaway
Dan Castellaneta (4)
Kelsey Grammer
Marcia Wallace
Yeardley Smith

X

ReplyCopy URL

[Dan Backslide Joined: Apr 24th, 2016 Topics: 45 Posts: 3252 View Predictions]

#1203489802

Seeing all those wins for Mary Tyler Moore Show reminds me of how bad I feel for Gavin MacLeod. The only main cast member to never be nominated, for which is particularly bad when you know that, with the exception of the once nominated Georgia Engel, every single other member of the main cast won an Emmy. At least MacLeod got a few Globe nods.

X

ReplyCopy URL

[BenitoDelicias Joined: Nov 3rd, 2010 Topics: 0 Posts: 496 View Predictions]

#1203489847

What’s surprising is that on that Drama list, only the first 2 shows won guest Emmys. I know guest categories haven’t been around forever, but still, there are recent-ish shows on that list.

X

ReplyCopy URL

[methaddiction Joined: Aug 1st, 2017 Topics: 3 Posts: 4232 View Predictions]

#1203489850

One of those wins for The Waltons was actually a guest appearance but they submitted in Lead and won due to the rule’s that year.

X

ReplyCopy URL

[Emmyfan Joined: Nov 26th, 2010 Topics: 16 Posts: 1553 View Predictions]

#1203490125

All In The Family has 11 acting wins:

4 for Carroll O’Connor
3 for Jean Stapleton
2 for Sally Struthers
2 for Rob Reiner

Dan Backslide wrote:

Seeing all those wins for Mary Tyler Moore Show reminds me of how bad I feel for Gavin MacLeod. The only main cast member to never be nominated, for which is particularly bad when you know that, with the exception of the once nominated Georgia Engel, every single other member of the main cast won an Emmy. At least MacLeod got a few Globe nods.

It is bad. I saw an acceptance speech made by Ted Knight and he mentioned Gavin.

X

ReplyCopy URL

[Madson Melo Joined: Jul 25th, 2011 Topics: 20 Posts: 310 View Predictions]

#1203490186

BenitoDelicias wrote:

What’s surprising is that on that Drama list, only the first 2 shows won guest Emmys. I know guest categories haven’t been around forever, but still, there are recent-ish shows on that list.

What really shooked me was the fact that ”The Practice” won 5 years in a row in the male guest category for 5 different actors. I mean, wow!

Emmyfan wrote:

All In The Family has 11 acting wins:

4 for Carroll O’Connor
3 for Jean Stapleton
2 for Sally Struthers
2 for Rob Reiner

thanks! somehow I didn’t count her last win in ’78!

X

ReplyCopy URL

[ricardo505 Joined: Jun 14th, 2015 Topics: 1 Posts: 559 View Predictions]

#1203490267

Doris Roberts and James Coco were guests when they won for St. Elsewhere. They literally just appeared in one episode of the series, according to imdb.

(I know there weren’t guest categories when they won, but I think it is something important to remember)

X

ReplyCopy URL

[Dan Backslide Joined: Apr 24th, 2016 Topics: 45 Posts: 3252 View Predictions]

#1203490291

Emmyfan wrote:

It is bad. I saw an acceptance speech made by Ted Knight and he mentioned Gavin.

Apparently the show even acknowledged it. I’m currently only on the second season, but I recall hearing about how they had an entire later on where the plot was based around MacLeod never being recognized with a story about how his character was the only person working for the channel who had yet to win an award.

X

ReplyCopy URL

[Tony Ruiz Joined: Nov 5th, 2010 Topics: 2 Posts: 40 View Predictions]

#1203493869

methaddiction wrote:

One of those wins for The Waltons was actually a guest appearance but they submitted in Lead and won due to the rule’s that year.

Correction…Beulah Bondi won for the category “Lead Actress in a Single Performance.” That’s more of a guest win.

X

ReplyCopy URL

[Jefty2000 Joined: Sep 27th, 2011 Topics: 0 Posts: 51 View Predictions]

#1203494173

madsonmelo wrote:

After a quick debate, I went to research what shows have won more Emmys for acting in all categories (not counting Super Emmys and whatsoever), I came up to these shows and decided to share just in case:

DRAMA:

1. The Practice – 13 (8 in Guest)
2. Picket Fences – 10 (3 in Guest)
3. The Sopranos – 9
3. The West Wing – 9
3. Breaking Bad – 9
3. The Waltons – 9
7. Hill Street Blues – 8
7. NYPD Blue – 8
9. St. Elsewhere – 7
9. Lou Grant – 7
9. Cagney & Lacey – 7

Almost there:
– The Handmaid’s Tale – 6
– Caesar’s Hour (never seen, was this scripted?) – 6
– Thirtysomething – 6
– Columbo – 6
– Law & Order: SVU – 6 (5 in Guest)

COMEDY

1. The Mary Tyler Moore Show – 15 (1 in Guest)
2. Frasier – 13 (5 in Guest)
3. Cheers – 12 (1 in Guest)
4. All in the Family – 11
5. Everybody Loves Raymond – 10
5. Murphy Brown – 10 (5 in Guest)
5. Mad About You – 10 (6 in Guest)
8. Will & Grace – 8 (3 in Guest)
8. Taxi – 8
8. Veep – 8

Almost there:
– The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel – 6 (2 in Guest)
– M*A*S*H – 6
– Modern Family – 6
– The Andy Griffith Show – 6

Have I missed a show? Have I counted anything wrong? Let me know!

The Practice has 9 wins in guest categories, not 8.

Four by series regulars: Cameryn Manheim, Michael Badalucco, Holland Taylor & James Spader

9 by guests: Jason Larroquette, Edward Herrmann, James Whitmore, Beah Richards, Michael Emerson, Charles S Dutton, Alfre Woodard, William Shatner & Sharon Stone

X

ReplyCopy URL

[wolfali Joined: Sep 4th, 2018 Topics: 200 Posts: 29526 View Predictions]

#1203494264

Maisel is going to get into the top 8 soon.

FYC:

"The Good Fight" and "The Other Two" in all categories.

X

ReplyCopy URL