[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203993127

John Berchmans wrote:

You probably heard that from one critic. Most others have been positive about the script.

I feel like the praise for the movie focused mainly on performances. Moreover, there are also reviews on letterboxd saying the script is all over the place and most of the pundits who have watched it are not predicting it in Screenplay. But we’ll see.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203992127

Cordelia wrote:

V ungr gung gur raqvat jnf ure qlvat naq gung gur cbyvpr fhqqrayl tbg gurve fuvg gbtrgure naq neerfgrq gur encvfgf. Znlor vg’f zl genaf rkcrevrapr, ohg qrngu qbrfa’g fhqqrayl znxr cerivbhfyl ncngurgvp cbyvpr vafgvghgvbaf tvir n fuvg. Naq shegurezber, gur vqrn bs n fnpevsvpvny qrngu univat zber inyhr V guvax vf cerggl shpxvat gbkvp gb zr – gur vqrn gung yvsr nsgre genhzn bs encr vf yrff inyhnoyr guna n fnpevsvpr. Gung vqrn znqr zr pbafvqre fhvpvqr nsgre orvat nffnhygrq, naq urer gur zbivr vf cerfragvat gung nf gur ivpgbel pbaqvgvba. V pna bayl nccerpvngr Pnerl Zhyyvtna’f cresbeznapr fb zhpu sbe fhpu n greevoyr fpevcg. Naq gung vf jul V pbzcnerq vg gb Gur Gevny bs gur Puvpntb 7 – guvf arbyvoreny vqrn gung hygvzngryl gurer jvyy or vafgvghgvbaf gung jvyy uryc lbh, naq gung lbh whfg arrq gb qb jung gurl jnag, rira vs gung’f tvivat hc lbhe yvsr.

I don’t think you quite got the ending of PYW. It’s not supposed to be a victory. Far from it.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203991970

Mank missing in Picture and Director again…I’ve been toying with the idea that the Globes will snub it in Drama too but I’m not brave enough to predict it.

Reply

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203991859

How unoriginal…

Reply

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203990781

Marcus.H wrote:

8/10 BP winners in these 10 years also won Best Screenplay. (Exceptions are The Artist, a silent film, and The Shape of Water, a fantasy film) Films which are predicted to win screenplay rn: -Chicago 7 (Original) -Nomadland (Adapted) -One Night in Miami (Adapted) (We don’t know about Judas yet.)

Heard the script for Judas is its biggest weakness being unfocused and all over the place.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203989204

Monsoon 🌊 wrote:

Carey deserves a nomination. But I wouldn’t be surprised if she’s snubbed Jake Gyllenhaal style (nominated at the precursors but snubbed at Oscars). PYW is a great film but it’s also very polarizing & that ending is divisive. A lot of older voters might be turned off.

The audience scores are great and most people have no problem with the ending. It even has 7.5 on the bros site IMDb. I mean this argument worked before it came out but now not so much. Also what’s with this bias against old people? I bet they will be less distressed about it than the younger crowd.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203989187

The only way Boseman could lose BA is if they reward him in Supporting. I’ve seen some critics and pundits pushing this path but I don’t know if voters will bite.

Reply

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203989184

Anne has been wrong plenty of times and by her own admission she hasn’t talked to many members this year. And not even dreaming to compare it to Parasite but PYW is the only movie this season that comes close to the passion Parasite had on social media. I don’t think it has a chance to win but I do think it’s getting that BP nomination.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203986742

Jazzy wrote:

Several days ago, someone posted the SAG Ensemble shortlist and PYW wasn’t on there.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203986159

Someone did this on AW with the BP contenders so I borrowed it because I think it’s interesting.

Highest rated movies by audiences on LB, IMDb and RT:

1. Soul – 84% (LB: 4.15, IMDb: 8.1, RT: 88%)
2. Sound of Metal – 83.47% (LB: 4.12, IMDb: 7.8, RT: 90%)
3. The Trial of the Chicago 7 – 81.2% (LB: 3.73, IMDb: 7.8, RT: 91%)
4. Minari – 81% (LB: 4.25, IMDb: 7.7, RT: -)
5. Nomadland – 80.2% (LB: 4.17, IMDb: 7.7, RT: -)
6. Promising Young Woman – 80.13% (LB: 3.87, IMDb: 7.4, RT: 89%)
7. The Father – 78.3% (LB: 4.08, IMDb: 7.5, RT: -)
8. One Night in Miami – 75.93% (LB: 3.79, IMDb: 6.8, RT: 84%)
9. News of the World – 75.27% (LB: 3,34, IMDb: 7, RT: 89%)
10. Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom – 73.73% (LB: 3.61, IMDb: 7.1, RT: 78%)
11. Mank – 67.27% (LB: 3.49, IMDb: 7.1, RT: 61%)
12. Da 5 Bloods – 63.27% (LB: 3.59, IMDb: 6.5, RT: 53%)

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203984885

JakeT wrote:

What is this age chat? Real relationships have age gaps, I don’t understand the issue here

Age gaps are fine but not if that’s all we see.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203984850

Jazzy wrote:

While I agree that PYW isn’t anything to write home about, Zendaya’s movie looks like it should be headed straight to the MTV movie awards. One of the main complaints about the trailer was that the movie looks like a music video. I actually wouldn’t be surprised at all if Zendaya does win an award at the MTV movie awards. As for PYW, it’s just such a strange movie, I can’t picture voters going out of their way to vote for Carey.

What’s so strange about it?

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203981031

Yelling on camera does not mean Oscar worthy. I wish Raci could win with this quiet performance just to see some of the reactions  BuT hE dIdn’T dO aNyThInG.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203978358

wolfali wrote:

Haha yes. I was just posting the winners just for fun. This in no way affects the Oscars race (only one of the contenders were nominated). Interesting nonetheless that Ahmed won too.

It will help Ahmed since he’s already on the verge of a nomination but Beharie is not happening.

[NevadaR Joined: Jan 13th, 2018 Topics: 0 Posts: 227 View Predictions]

#1203972760

JGibson wrote:

watch hfpa drop a fincher cause theyre that much of a cunt

It would look so freaking bad if they did it. I hope they won’t be this dumb and tone-deaf.