Editors' Predicted Winners
Tony Awards Nominations 2023 (Overall Accuracy: 76.67%)
HUB
BY
Best Musical
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    1

    Kimberly Akimbo

    12
    11
    16/5
  • Some Like it Hot
    2

    Some Like it Hot

    12
    0
    39/10
  • & Juliet
    3

    & Juliet

    12
    1
    4/1
  • Shucked
    4

    Shucked

    10
    0
    11/2
  • New York, New York
    5

    New York, New York

    10
    0
    11/2
  • Bad Cinderella
    6

    Bad Cinderella

    1
    0
    64/1
  • Almost Famous
    7

    Almost Famous

    1
    0
    66/1
  • KPOP
    8

    KPOP

    1
    0
    66/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    9

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    1
    0
    66/1
Best Play
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Leopoldstadt
    1

    Leopoldstadt

    12
    11
    16/5
  • Fat Ham
    2

    Fat Ham

    12
    0
    4/1
  • Life of Pi
    3

    Life of Pi

    12
    1
    4/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    4

    Between Riverside and Crazy

    11
    0
    5/1
  • Ain't No Mo'
    5

    Ain't No Mo'

    6
    0
    10/1
  • Cost of Living
    6

    Cost of Living

    3
    0
    20/1
  • Good Night, Oscar
    7

    Good Night, Oscar

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Prima Facie
    8

    Prima Facie

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Mike Birbiglia: The Old Man & the Pool
    9

    Mike Birbiglia: The Old Man & The Pool

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    10

    Peter Pan Goes Wrong

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Collaboration
    11

    The Collaboration

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    12

    The Kite Runner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • A Christmas Carol
    13

    A Christmas Carol

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Walking With Ghosts
    14

    Walking With Ghosts

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Thanksgiving Play
    15

    The Thanksgiving Play

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Summer, 1976
    16

    Summer, 1976

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Pictures From Home
    17

    Pictures From Home

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Musical Revival
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Sweeney Todd
    1

    Sweeney Todd

    12
    11
    12/5
  • Into the Woods
    2

    Into the Woods

    12
    1
    31/10
  • Parade
    3

    Parade

    12
    0
    16/5
  • Camelot
    4

    Camelot

    8
    0
    6/1
  • Dancin'
    5

    Dancin'

    2
    0
    25/1
  • 1776
    6

    1776

    2
    0
    25/1
Best Play Revival
Accuracy: 75%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • The Piano Lesson
    1

    The Piano Lesson

    12
    9
    47/20
  • Death of a Salesman
    2

    Death of a Salesman

    12
    2
    14/5
  • A Doll's House
    3

    A Doll's House

    11
    0
    71/20
  • Topdog/Underdog
    4

    Topdog/Underdog

    10
    1
    4/1
  • Rachel-Brosnahan
    5

    The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window

    1
    0
    46/1
  • Ohio State Murders
    6

    Ohio State Murders

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actress (Musical)
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Victoria Clark
    1

    Victoria Clark

    12
    10
    82/25
  • Annaleigh Ashford
    2

    Annaleigh Ashford

    12
    2
    37/10
  • Micaela Diamond
    3

    Micaela Diamond

    12
    0
    9/2
  • Sara Bareilles
    4

    Sara Bareilles

    12
    0
    9/2
  • Patina Miller
    5

    Patina Miller

    6
    0
    10/1
  • Lorna Courtney
    6

    Lorna Courtney

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Phillipa Soo
    7

    Phillipa Soo

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Anna Uzele
    8

    Anna Uzele

    1
    0
    66/1
  • Adrianna Hicks
    9

    Adrianna Hicks

    1
    0
    66/1
  • Luna
    10

    Luna

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Crystal Lucas-Perry
    11

    Crystal Lucas-Perry

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Caroline Innerbichler
    12

    Caroline Innerbichler

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Linedy Genao
    13

    Linedy Genao

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actor (Musical)
Accuracy: 83.33%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • J. Harrison Ghee
    1

    J. Harrison Ghee

    12
    7
    69/20
  • Josh Groban
    2

    Josh Groban

    12
    5
    18/5
  • Ben Platt
    3

    Ben Platt

    12
    0
    9/2
  • Brian d'Arcy James
    4

    Brian d'Arcy James

    11
    0
    5/1
  • Christian Borle
    5

    Christian Borle

    9
    0
    6/1
  • Will Swenson
    6

    Will Swenson

    3
    0
    22/1
  • Colton-Ryan
    7

    Colton Ryan

    1
    0
    66/1
  • Andrew-Burnap
    8

    Andrew Burnap

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    9

    Casey Likes

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actress (Play)
Accuracy: 75%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • jodie-comer
    1

    Jodie Comer

    12
    9
    5/2
  • Jessica Chastain
    2

    Jessica Chastain

    11
    3
    16/5
  • Audra McDonald
    3

    Audra McDonald

    12
    0
    82/25
  • laura linney
    4

    Laura Linney

    9
    0
    5/1
  • Rachel Brosnahan
    5

    Rachel Brosnahan

    3
    0
    18/1
  • Jessica Hecht
    6

    Jessica Hecht

    1
    0
    54/1
  • Zoe Wanamaker
    7

    Zoe Wanamaker

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actor (Play)
Accuracy: 60%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Wendell Pierce
    1

    Wendell Pierce

    12
    9
    10/3
  • Sean Hayes
    2

    Sean Hayes

    12
    3
    19/5
  • Marcel Spears
    3

    Marcel Spears

    11
    0
    9/2
  • Stephen McKinley Henderson
    4

    Stephen McKinley Henderson

    10
    0
    11/2
  • John David Washington
    5

    John David Washington

    9
    0
    6/1
  • Jefferson Mays
    6

    Jefferson Mays

    2
    0
    30/1
  • Hiran Abeysekera
    7

    Hiran Abeysekera

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Corey Hawkins
    8

    Corey Hawkins

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Amir Arison
    9

    Amir Arison

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Danny Burstein
    10

    Danny Burstein

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Gabriel Byrne
    11

    Gabriel Byrne

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Oscar Isaac
    12

    Oscar Isaac

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Mike Birbiglia
    13

    Mike Birbiglia

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Jeremy Pope
    14

    Jeremy Pope

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Paul Bettany
    15

    Paul Bettany

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Yahya-Abdul-Mateen-II
    16

    Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Nathan Lane
    17

    Nathan Lane

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actress (Musical)
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Bonnie Milligan
    1

    Bonnie Milligan

    12
    10
    82/25
  • Betsy Wolfe
    2

    Betsy Wolfe

    12
    1
    39/10
  • NaTasha Yvette Williams
    3

    NaTasha Yvette Williams

    12
    1
    4/1
  • Ruthie Ann Miles
    4

    Ruthie Ann Miles

    7
    0
    17/2
  • Julia Lester
    5

    Julia Lester

    5
    0
    12/1
  • Robyn Hurder
    6

    Robyn Hurder

    5
    0
    12/1
  • Alli Mauzey
    7

    Alli Mauzey

    3
    0
    20/1
  • Phillipa Soo
    8

    Phillipa Soo

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Melanie La Barrie
    9

    Melanie La Barrie

    1
    0
    62/1
  • 1776
    10

    Eryn Lecroy

    1
    0
    64/1
  • Sweeney Todd
    11

    Maria Bilbao

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Carolee Carmello
    12

    Carolee Carmello

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Carolee Carmello
    13

    Carolee Carmello

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Courtnee Carter
    14

    Courtnee Carter

    0
    0
    100/1
  • New York, New York
    15

    Janet Dacal

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    16

    Elizabeth A. Davis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ashley D. Kelley
    17

    Ashley D. Kelley

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Anika Larsen
    18

    Anika Larsen

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Grace McLean
    19

    Grace McLean

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Solea Pfeiffer
    20

    Solea Pfeiffer

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    21

    Sara Porkalob

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Emily Skinner
    22

    Emily Skinner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Marliee Talkington
    23

    Marilee Talkington

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actor (Musical)
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Justin Cooley
    1

    Justin Cooley

    12
    9
    10/3
  • Gavin Creel
    2

    Gavin Creel

    12
    1
    4/1
  • Alex Newell
    3

    Alex Newell

    10
    2
    5/1
  • Kevin Del Aguila
    4

    Kevin Del Aguila

    10
    0
    11/2
  • Jordan Donica
    5

    Jordan Donica

    9
    0
    6/1
  • Alex Joseph Grayson
    6

    Alex Joseph Grayson

    3
    0
    22/1
  • Gaten Matarazzo
    7

    Gaten Matarazzo

    2
    0
    33/1
  • & Juliet
    8

    Paulo Szot

    1
    0
    58/1
  • Steven Boyer
    9

    Steven Boyer

    1
    0
    66/1
  • Almost Famous
    10

    Drew Gehling

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Joshua Henry
    11

    Joshua Henry

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Grey Henson
    12

    Grey Henson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    13

    Mark Jacoby

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sweeney Todd
    14

    Jamie Jackson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Into the Woods
    15

    Kennedy Kanagawa

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sean Allan Krill
    16

    Sean Allan Krill

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Camelot
    17

    Dakin Matthews

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Howard McGillin
    18

    Howard McGillin

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Paul Alexander Nolan
    19

    Paul Alexander Nolan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Stark Sands
    20

    Stark Sands

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Taylor Trensch
    21

    Taylor Trensch

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Dancin'
    22

    Kolton Krouse

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Jordan Fisher
    23

    Jordan Fisher

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Andrew Durand
    24

    Andrew Durand

    0
    0
    100/1
  • New York, New York
    25

    Clyde Alves

    0
    0
    100/1
  • John Behlmann
    26

    John Behlmann

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Kevin Cahoon
    27

    Kevin Cahoon

    0
    0
    100/1
  • John Clay III
    28

    John Clay III

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Jordan Dobson
    29

    Jordan Dobson

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actress (Play)
Accuracy: 40%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Sharon D Clarke
    1

    Sharon D Clarke

    12
    10
    82/25
  • Danielle Brooks
    2

    Danielle Brooks

    12
    1
    39/10
  • Crystal Lucas-Perry
    3

    Crystal Lucas-Perry

    10
    1
    5/1
  • Katy Sullivan
    4

    Katy Sullivan

    10
    0
    11/2
  • Leopoldstadt
    5

    Faye Castelow

    10
    0
    11/2
  • d'arcy carden
    6

    D'Arcy Carden

    3
    0
    20/1
  • Liza Colon-Zayas
    7

    Liza Colon-Zayas

    1
    0
    58/1
  • Caissie Levy
    8

    Caissie Levy

    1
    0
    62/1
  • Miriam Silverman
    9

    Miriam Silverman

    1
    0
    66/1
  • Emily Bergl
    10

    Emily Bergl

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    11

    Elizabeth Canavan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Rosal Colon
    12

    Rosal Colon

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Nikki Crawford
    13

    Nikki Crawford

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Katie Finneran
    14

    Katie Finneran

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Fedna Jacquet
    15

    Fedna Jacquet

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ebony Marshall-Oliver
    16

    Ebony Marshall-Oliver

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Fat Ham
    17

    Adrianna Mitchell

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    18

    Ellie Morris

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Krysta Rodriguez
    19

    Krysta Rodriguez

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Benja Kay Thomas
    20

    Benja Kay Thomas

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Kara Young
    21

    Kara Young

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Nancy Zamit
    22

    Nancy Zamit

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actor (Play)
Accuracy: 60%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Brandon Uranowitz
    1

    Brandon Uranowitz

    12
    6
    7/2
  • Samuel L. Jackson
    2

    Samuel L. Jackson

    12
    6
    71/20
  • David Krumholtz
    3

    David Krumholtz

    10
    0
    11/2
  • Arian Moayed
    4

    Arian Moayed

    10
    0
    11/2
  • André De Shields
    5

    André De Shields

    6
    0
    17/2
  • Jordan E. Cooper
    6

    Jordan E. Cooper

    5
    0
    15/1
  • Ray Fisher
    7

    Ray Fisher

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Chris Herbie Holland
    8

    Chris Herbie Holland

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Scott Foley
    9

    Scott Foley

    1
    0
    64/1
  • Erik Jensen
    10

    Erik Jensen

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Fat Ham
    11

    Billy Eugene Jones

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Andy Grotelueschen
    12

    Andy Grotelueschen

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    13

    Henry Lewis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Gregg Mozgala
    14

    Gregg Mozgala

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Seth Numrich
    15

    Seth Numrich

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Okieriete Onaodowan
    16

    Okieriete Onaodowan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Michael Potts
    17

    Michael Potts

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ben Rappaport
    18

    Ben Rappaport

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Michael Rispoli
    19

    Michael Rispoli

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    20

    Jonathan Sayer

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    21

    Henry Shields

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Calvin Leon Smith
    22

    Calvin Leon Smith

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Chris Sullivan
    23

    Chris Sullivan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    24

    Faran Tahir

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Arty Froushan
    25

    Arty Froushan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Marchant Davis
    26

    Marchant Davis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    27

    Victor Almazar

    0
    0
    100/1
  • McKinley Belcher
    28

    McKinley Belcher III

    0
    0
    100/1
  • common
    29

    Common

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Khris Davis
    30

    Khris Davis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • David Zayas
    31

    David Zayas

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Director (Musical)
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Sweeney Todd
    1

    Sweeney Todd

    12
    6
    7/2
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    2

    Kimberly Akimbo

    12
    6
    7/2
  • Some Like it Hot
    3

    Some Like it Hot

    11
    0
    5/1
  • Into the Woods
    4

    Into the Woods

    9
    0
    13/2
  • Parade
    5

    Parade

    8
    0
    7/1
  • & Juliet
    6

    & Juliet

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Shucked
    7

    Shucked

    2
    0
    33/1
  • New York, New York
    8

    New York, New York

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Camelot
    9

    Camelot

    1
    0
    64/1
  • 1776
    10

    1776

    1
    0
    66/1
  • KPOP
    11

    KPOP

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Dancin'
    12

    Dancin'

    0
    0
    100/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    13

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    14

    Bad Cinderella

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    15

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Director (Play)
Accuracy: 50%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Leopoldstadt
    1

    Leopoldstadt

    12
    9
    10/3
  • Life of Pi
    2

    Life of Pi

    12
    3
    37/10
  • The Piano Lesson
    3

    The Piano Lesson

    12
    0
    9/2
  • Fat Ham
    4

    Fat Ham

    11
    0
    5/1
  • Topdog/Underdog
    5

    Topdog/Underdog

    6
    0
    10/1
  • Death of a Salesman
    6

    Death of a Salesman

    3
    0
    22/1
  • A Doll's House
    7

    A Doll's House

    2
    0
    33/1
  • A Christmas Carol
    8

    A Christmas Carol

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Rachel-Brosnahan
    9

    The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Good Night, Oscar
    10

    Good Night, Oscar

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ain't No Mo'
    11

    Ain't No Mo'

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Walking With Ghosts
    12

    Walking With Ghosts

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Prima Facie
    13

    Prima Facie

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    14

    Between Riverside and Crazy

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Thanksgiving Play
    15

    The Thanksgiving Play

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Pictures From Home
    16

    Pictures From Home

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Cost of Living
    17

    Cost of Living

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Summer, 1976
    18

    Summer, 1976

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    19

    Peter Pan Goes Wrong

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    20

    The Kite Runner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Collaboration
    21

    The Collaboration

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ohio State Murders
    22

    Ohio State Murders

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Original Score
Accuracy: 60%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    1

    Kimberly Akimbo

    12
    11
    16/5
  • Some Like it Hot
    2

    Some Like it Hot

    12
    1
    19/5
  • Life of Pi
    3

    Life of Pi

    12
    0
    9/2
  • Shucked
    4

    Shucked

    11
    0
    9/2
  • Bad Cinderella
    5

    Bad Cinderella

    9
    0
    13/2
  • Leopoldstadt
    6

    Leopoldstadt

    2
    0
    33/1
  • KPOP
    7

    KPOP

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Almost Famous
    8

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Cost of Living
    9

    Cost of Living

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Death of a Salesman
    10

    Death of a Salesman

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    11

    The Kite Runner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Piano Lesson
    12

    The Piano Lesson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Prima Facie
    13

    Prima Facie

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Musical Book
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    1

    Kimberly Akimbo

    12
    10
    82/25
  • Some Like it Hot
    2

    Some Like it Hot

    12
    0
    4/1
  • & Juliet
    3

    & Juliet

    12
    1
    4/1
  • Shucked
    4

    Shucked

    10
    1
    11/2
  • New York, New York
    5

    New York, New York

    8
    0
    13/2
  • Camelot
    6

    Camelot

    4
    0
    22/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    7

    Bad Cinderella

    2
    0
    33/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    8

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    9

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
  • KPOP
    10

    KPOP

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Choreography
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Some Like it Hot
    1

    Some Like it Hot

    12
    9
    10/3
  • New York, New York
    2

    New York, New York

    12
    2
    19/5
  • & Juliet
    3

    & Juliet

    11
    1
    9/2
  • KPOP
    4

    KPOP

    11
    0
    5/1
  • Shucked
    5

    Shucked

    8
    0
    7/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    6

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    4
    0
    16/1
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    7

    Kimberly Akimbo

    2
    0
    33/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    8

    Bad Cinderella

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Camelot
    9

    Camelot

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Into the Woods
    10

    Into the Woods

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    11

    1776

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    12

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sweeney Todd
    13

    Sweeney Todd

    0
    0
    100/1