All-Star Top 24 Users' Predicted Winners
Tony Awards Nominations 2023 (Overall Accuracy: 78.63%)
HUB
BY

Current predictions by our Users who had the best scores over the past two years. If a user in our Top 24 has not yet returned to make new picks, this list populates with the next user who has the next score. See leaderboard. See leaderboard

Best Musical
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    1

    Kimberly Akimbo

    24
    22
    16/5
  • Some Like it Hot
    2

    Some Like it Hot

    24
    1
    39/10
  • & Juliet
    3

    & Juliet

    24
    0
    9/2
  • New York, New York
    4

    New York, New York

    24
    1
    9/2
  • Shucked
    5

    Shucked

    23
    0
    9/2
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    6

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    1
    0
    100/1
  • KPOP
    7

    KPOP

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    8

    Bad Cinderella

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    9

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Play
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Leopoldstadt
    1

    Leopoldstadt

    24
    20
    82/25
  • Fat Ham
    2

    Fat Ham

    24
    2
    39/10
  • Life of Pi
    3

    Life of Pi

    22
    2
    9/2
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    4

    Between Riverside and Crazy

    21
    0
    5/1
  • Ain't No Mo'
    5

    Ain't No Mo'

    11
    0
    21/2
  • Cost of Living
    6

    Cost of Living

    8
    0
    15/1
  • Prima Facie
    7

    Prima Facie

    8
    0
    16/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    8

    Peter Pan Goes Wrong

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Good Night, Oscar
    9

    Good Night, Oscar

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Mike Birbiglia: The Old Man & the Pool
    10

    Mike Birbiglia: The Old Man & The Pool

    0
    0
    100/1
  • A Christmas Carol
    11

    A Christmas Carol

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Collaboration
    12

    The Collaboration

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    13

    The Kite Runner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Summer, 1976
    14

    Summer, 1976

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Pictures From Home
    15

    Pictures From Home

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Thanksgiving Play
    16

    The Thanksgiving Play

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Walking With Ghosts
    17

    Walking With Ghosts

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Musical Revival
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Sweeney Todd
    1

    Sweeney Todd

    24
    15
    51/20
  • Into the Woods
    2

    Into the Woods

    24
    5
    59/20
  • Parade
    3

    Parade

    24
    2
    31/10
  • Camelot
    4

    Camelot

    20
    2
    9/2
  • Dancin'
    5

    Dancin'

    4
    0
    25/1
  • 1776
    6

    1776

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Play Revival
Accuracy: 75%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • The Piano Lesson
    1

    The Piano Lesson

    24
    19
    49/20
  • Death of a Salesman
    2

    Death of a Salesman

    23
    2
    16/5
  • A Doll's House
    3

    A Doll's House

    22
    1
    37/10
  • Topdog/Underdog
    4

    Topdog/Underdog

    21
    2
    39/10
  • Rachel-Brosnahan
    5

    The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window

    6
    0
    18/1
  • Ohio State Murders
    6

    Ohio State Murders

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actress (Musical)
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Victoria Clark
    1

    Victoria Clark

    24
    22
    82/25
  • Annaleigh Ashford
    2

    Annaleigh Ashford

    24
    1
    39/10
  • Micaela Diamond
    3

    Micaela Diamond

    24
    0
    4/1
  • Sara Bareilles
    4

    Sara Bareilles

    22
    1
    5/1
  • Anna Uzele
    5

    Anna Uzele

    13
    0
    9/1
  • Patina Miller
    6

    Patina Miller

    7
    0
    18/1
  • Adrianna Hicks
    7

    Adrianna Hicks

    3
    0
    44/1
  • Caroline Innerbichler
    8

    Caroline Innerbichler

    2
    0
    66/1
  • Phillipa Soo
    9

    Phillipa Soo

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Crystal Lucas-Perry
    10

    Crystal Lucas-Perry

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Luna
    11

    Luna

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Linedy Genao
    12

    Linedy Genao

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Lorna Courtney
    13

    Lorna Courtney

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actor (Musical)
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Josh Groban
    1

    Josh Groban

    24
    12
    7/2
  • J. Harrison Ghee
    2

    J. Harrison Ghee

    24
    11
    18/5
  • Ben Platt
    3

    Ben Platt

    24
    1
    4/1
  • Christian Borle
    4

    Christian Borle

    14
    0
    8/1
  • Brian d'Arcy James
    5

    Brian d'Arcy James

    12
    0
    10/1
  • Colton-Ryan
    6

    Colton Ryan

    11
    0
    11/1
  • Will Swenson
    7

    Will Swenson

    8
    0
    15/1
  • Andrew-Burnap
    8

    Andrew Burnap

    3
    0
    42/1
  • Almost Famous
    9

    Casey Likes

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actress (Play)
Accuracy: 75%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • jodie-comer
    1

    Jodie Comer

    24
    14
    13/5
  • Jessica Chastain
    2

    Jessica Chastain

    24
    9
    27/10
  • Audra McDonald
    3

    Audra McDonald

    24
    1
    82/25
  • laura linney
    4

    Laura Linney

    15
    0
    6/1
  • Rachel Brosnahan
    5

    Rachel Brosnahan

    8
    0
    13/1
  • Jessica Hecht
    6

    Jessica Hecht

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Zoe Wanamaker
    7

    Zoe Wanamaker

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Actor (Play)
Accuracy: 60%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Wendell Pierce
    1

    Wendell Pierce

    24
    18
    10/3
  • Sean Hayes
    2

    Sean Hayes

    23
    2
    9/2
  • Marcel Spears
    3

    Marcel Spears

    21
    1
    5/1
  • Stephen McKinley Henderson
    4

    Stephen McKinley Henderson

    17
    1
    13/2
  • John David Washington
    5

    John David Washington

    12
    2
    9/1
  • Hiran Abeysekera
    6

    Hiran Abeysekera

    12
    0
    10/1
  • Corey Hawkins
    7

    Corey Hawkins

    5
    0
    25/1
  • Jefferson Mays
    8

    Jefferson Mays

    4
    0
    33/1
  • Oscar Isaac
    9

    Oscar Isaac

    2
    0
    64/1
  • Gabriel Byrne
    10

    Gabriel Byrne

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Jeremy Pope
    11

    Jeremy Pope

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Nathan Lane
    12

    Nathan Lane

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Danny Burstein
    13

    Danny Burstein

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Yahya-Abdul-Mateen-II
    14

    Yahya Abdul-Mateen II

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Amir Arison
    15

    Amir Arison

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Paul Bettany
    16

    Paul Bettany

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Mike Birbiglia
    17

    Mike Birbiglia

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actress (Musical)
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Bonnie Milligan
    1

    Bonnie Milligan

    24
    22
    16/5
  • Betsy Wolfe
    2

    Betsy Wolfe

    24
    2
    39/10
  • NaTasha Yvette Williams
    3

    NaTasha Yvette Williams

    21
    0
    5/1
  • Julia Lester
    4

    Julia Lester

    15
    0
    15/2
  • Ruthie Ann Miles
    5

    Ruthie Ann Miles

    13
    0
    9/1
  • Alli Mauzey
    6

    Alli Mauzey

    11
    0
    21/2
  • Robyn Hurder
    7

    Robyn Hurder

    6
    0
    20/1
  • Phillipa Soo
    8

    Phillipa Soo

    5
    0
    25/1
  • Carolee Carmello
    9

    Carolee Carmello

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Melanie La Barrie
    10

    Melanie La Barrie

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Anika Larsen
    11

    Anika Larsen

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Grace McLean
    12

    Grace McLean

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Solea Pfeiffer
    13

    Solea Pfeiffer

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    14

    Sara Porkalob

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Emily Skinner
    15

    Emily Skinner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Marliee Talkington
    16

    Marilee Talkington

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ashley D. Kelley
    17

    Ashley D. Kelley

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sweeney Todd
    18

    Maria Bilbao

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Carolee Carmello
    19

    Carolee Carmello

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Courtnee Carter
    20

    Courtnee Carter

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    21

    Elizabeth A. Davis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    22

    Eryn Lecroy

    0
    0
    100/1
  • New York, New York
    23

    Janet Dacal

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actor (Musical)
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Justin Cooley
    1

    Justin Cooley

    23
    14
    18/5
  • Alex Newell
    2

    Alex Newell

    23
    6
    4/1
  • Kevin Del Aguila
    3

    Kevin Del Aguila

    21
    1
    5/1
  • Gavin Creel
    4

    Gavin Creel

    16
    1
    13/2
  • Jordan Donica
    5

    Jordan Donica

    15
    2
    15/2
  • Gaten Matarazzo
    6

    Gaten Matarazzo

    9
    0
    14/1
  • Steven Boyer
    7

    Steven Boyer

    4
    0
    33/1
  • Alex Joseph Grayson
    8

    Alex Joseph Grayson

    3
    0
    42/1
  • Kevin Cahoon
    9

    Kevin Cahoon

    3
    0
    44/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    10

    Mark Jacoby

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Andrew Durand
    11

    Andrew Durand

    1
    0
    100/1
  • & Juliet
    12

    Paulo Szot

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Into the Woods
    13

    Kennedy Kanagawa

    0
    0
    100/1
  • New York, New York
    14

    Clyde Alves

    0
    0
    100/1
  • John Behlmann
    15

    John Behlmann

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Paul Alexander Nolan
    16

    Paul Alexander Nolan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Stark Sands
    17

    Stark Sands

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Taylor Trensch
    18

    Taylor Trensch

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Dancin'
    19

    Kolton Krouse

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Howard McGillin
    20

    Howard McGillin

    0
    0
    100/1
  • John Clay III
    21

    John Clay III

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Jordan Dobson
    22

    Jordan Dobson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Jordan Fisher
    23

    Jordan Fisher

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    24

    Drew Gehling

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Joshua Henry
    25

    Joshua Henry

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Grey Henson
    26

    Grey Henson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sweeney Todd
    27

    Jamie Jackson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sean Allan Krill
    28

    Sean Allan Krill

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Camelot
    29

    Dakin Matthews

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actress (Play)
Accuracy: 40%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Sharon D Clarke
    1

    Sharon D Clarke

    24
    18
    10/3
  • Danielle Brooks
    2

    Danielle Brooks

    24
    6
    37/10
  • Katy Sullivan
    3

    Katy Sullivan

    20
    0
    11/2
  • Crystal Lucas-Perry
    4

    Crystal Lucas-Perry

    19
    0
    6/1
  • Leopoldstadt
    5

    Faye Castelow

    17
    0
    13/2
  • Nikki Crawford
    6

    Nikki Crawford

    5
    0
    25/1
  • Miriam Silverman
    7

    Miriam Silverman

    4
    0
    30/1
  • d'arcy carden
    8

    D'Arcy Carden

    4
    0
    33/1
  • Liza Colon-Zayas
    9

    Liza Colon-Zayas

    2
    0
    64/1
  • Nancy Zamit
    10

    Nancy Zamit

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Rosal Colon
    11

    Rosal Colon

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Katie Finneran
    12

    Katie Finneran

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Fedna Jacquet
    13

    Fedna Jacquet

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Caissie Levy
    14

    Caissie Levy

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ebony Marshall-Oliver
    15

    Ebony Marshall-Oliver

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Emily Bergl
    16

    Emily Bergl

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    17

    Elizabeth Canavan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Fat Ham
    18

    Adrianna Mitchell

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    19

    Ellie Morris

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Krysta Rodriguez
    20

    Krysta Rodriguez

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Benja Kay Thomas
    21

    Benja Kay Thomas

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Kara Young
    22

    Kara Young

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Featured Actor (Play)
Accuracy: 60%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Brandon Uranowitz
    1

    Brandon Uranowitz

    24
    12
    7/2
  • Samuel L. Jackson
    2

    Samuel L. Jackson

    21
    11
    4/1
  • Arian Moayed
    3

    Arian Moayed

    24
    0
    9/2
  • David Krumholtz
    4

    David Krumholtz

    20
    0
    11/2
  • André De Shields
    5

    André De Shields

    13
    0
    9/1
  • Jordan E. Cooper
    6

    Jordan E. Cooper

    6
    0
    20/1
  • Ray Fisher
    7

    Ray Fisher

    5
    1
    25/1
  • David Zayas
    8

    David Zayas

    4
    0
    33/1
  • Chris Herbie Holland
    9

    Chris Herbie Holland

    2
    0
    64/1
  • Michael Potts
    10

    Michael Potts

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    11

    Jonathan Sayer

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    12

    Henry Lewis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Gregg Mozgala
    13

    Gregg Mozgala

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Seth Numrich
    14

    Seth Numrich

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Okieriete Onaodowan
    15

    Okieriete Onaodowan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ben Rappaport
    16

    Ben Rappaport

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Michael Rispoli
    17

    Michael Rispoli

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    18

    Henry Shields

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Calvin Leon Smith
    19

    Calvin Leon Smith

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Chris Sullivan
    20

    Chris Sullivan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    21

    Faran Tahir

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Fat Ham
    22

    Billy Eugene Jones

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Erik Jensen
    23

    Erik Jensen

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    24

    Victor Almazar

    0
    0
    100/1
  • McKinley Belcher
    25

    McKinley Belcher III

    0
    0
    100/1
  • common
    26

    Common

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Khris Davis
    27

    Khris Davis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Marchant Davis
    28

    Marchant Davis

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Scott Foley
    29

    Scott Foley

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Arty Froushan
    30

    Arty Froushan

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Andy Grotelueschen
    31

    Andy Grotelueschen

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Director (Musical)
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Sweeney Todd
    1

    Sweeney Todd

    24
    15
    69/20
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    2

    Kimberly Akimbo

    24
    7
    37/10
  • Some Like it Hot
    3

    Some Like it Hot

    24
    1
    4/1
  • Parade
    4

    Parade

    21
    0
    5/1
  • Into the Woods
    5

    Into the Woods

    13
    1
    9/1
  • Shucked
    6

    Shucked

    7
    0
    18/1
  • New York, New York
    7

    New York, New York

    5
    0
    25/1
  • Camelot
    8

    Camelot

    2
    0
    64/1
  • & Juliet
    9

    & Juliet

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    10

    1776

    0
    0
    100/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    11

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Dancin'
    12

    Dancin'

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    13

    Bad Cinderella

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    14

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
  • KPOP
    15

    KPOP

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Director (Play)
Accuracy: 66.67%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Leopoldstadt
    1

    Leopoldstadt

    24
    16
    17/5
  • Life of Pi
    2

    Life of Pi

    24
    6
    19/5
  • Fat Ham
    3

    Fat Ham

    22
    1
    5/1
  • The Piano Lesson
    4

    The Piano Lesson

    20
    1
    11/2
  • Topdog/Underdog
    5

    Topdog/Underdog

    17
    0
    7/1
  • A Doll's House
    6

    A Doll's House

    4
    0
    30/1
  • Death of a Salesman
    7

    Death of a Salesman

    3
    0
    42/1
  • Peter Pan Goes Wrong
    8

    Peter Pan Goes Wrong

    2
    0
    64/1
  • A Christmas Carol
    9

    A Christmas Carol

    2
    0
    66/1
  • Prima Facie
    10

    Prima Facie

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Cost of Living
    11

    Cost of Living

    1
    0
    100/1
  • The Thanksgiving Play
    12

    The Thanksgiving Play

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Walking With Ghosts
    13

    Walking With Ghosts

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Between Riverside and Crazy
    14

    Between Riverside and Crazy

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Rachel-Brosnahan
    15

    The Sign in Sidney Brustein's Window

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Good Night, Oscar
    16

    Good Night, Oscar

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Collaboration
    17

    The Collaboration

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ain't No Mo'
    18

    Ain't No Mo'

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Ohio State Murders
    19

    Ohio State Murders

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    20

    The Kite Runner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Pictures From Home
    21

    Pictures From Home

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Summer, 1976
    22

    Summer, 1976

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Original Score
Accuracy: 60%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    1

    Kimberly Akimbo

    24
    22
    16/5
  • Some Like it Hot
    2

    Some Like it Hot

    24
    2
    19/5
  • Shucked
    3

    Shucked

    24
    0
    9/2
  • Life of Pi
    4

    Life of Pi

    23
    0
    9/2
  • Bad Cinderella
    5

    Bad Cinderella

    16
    0
    7/1
  • KPOP
    6

    KPOP

    6
    0
    22/1
  • Leopoldstadt
    7

    Leopoldstadt

    2
    0
    66/1
  • Almost Famous
    8

    Almost Famous

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Prima Facie
    9

    Prima Facie

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Piano Lesson
    10

    The Piano Lesson

    0
    0
    100/1
  • The Kite Runner
    11

    The Kite Runner

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Death of a Salesman
    12

    Death of a Salesman

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Cost of Living
    13

    Cost of Living

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Musical Book
Accuracy: 100%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    1

    Kimberly Akimbo

    24
    24
    16/5
  • Some Like it Hot
    2

    Some Like it Hot

    24
    0
    4/1
  • Shucked
    3

    Shucked

    23
    0
    9/2
  • & Juliet
    4

    & Juliet

    23
    0
    9/2
  • New York, New York
    5

    New York, New York

    15
    0
    15/2
  • Camelot
    6

    Camelot

    10
    0
    12/1
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    7

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    1
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    8

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    9

    Bad Cinderella

    0
    0
    100/1
  • KPOP
    10

    KPOP

    0
    0
    100/1
Best Choreography
Accuracy: 80%
Nominee
Predict Nomination
Predict Win
Odds
  • Some Like it Hot
    1

    Some Like it Hot

    24
    20
    82/25
  • New York, New York
    2

    New York, New York

    24
    4
    37/10
  • & Juliet
    3

    & Juliet

    24
    0
    9/2
  • KPOP
    4

    KPOP

    21
    0
    5/1
  • Shucked
    5

    Shucked

    21
    0
    11/2
  • A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical
    6

    A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical

    6
    0
    22/1
  • Into the Woods
    7

    Into the Woods

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Camelot
    8

    Camelot

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Kimberly Akimbo
    9

    Kimberly Akimbo

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Sweeney Todd
    10

    Sweeney Todd

    0
    0
    100/1
  • 1776
    11

    1776

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Bad Cinderella
    12

    Bad Cinderella

    0
    0
    100/1
  • Almost Famous
    13

    Almost Famous

    0
    0
    100/1